Reef Check Foundation
Coral Reef Diagnostics

Indonesia - Banda Islands: Lighthouse

Coral Triangle Center (CTC)
⬇ Download this page as a report card
05
Coral Reef Diagnostics
Photo: Anderson Mayfield/Coral Reef Diagnostics
Country
Survey date(s)
2018-04-25
2018-04-26
Coordinates
-4.5150, 129.9000
Approximate position: no GPS fix was logged for this dive.
Coral cover
29%
Claude computer vision (133 edited photos) · other methods below · median 25%
Observations
Heat stress
Most recent heat load record
26 Oct 2026 · No heat stress
5-year thermal stress load
5-year mean max. degree heating weeks (DHW)
2021–2025
NOAA Coral Reef Watch — Maluku, Indonesia virtual station
i 5-year mean max. DHW is the mean of the annual maximum DHWs over the five complete years named above, not conditions today.
More infoMaluku, Indonesia (NOAA CRW virtual station)
Photographs
178
19 shown on this page
Site summary
Read this summary in:

Three dives here on 25 and 26 April 2018, one of them at night, show two faces of the site: a sunlit coral terrace of branching and columnar colonies cut by white sand channels, and a steep slope of large angular boulders carrying little coral. Frames Anderson recorded as crown-of-thorns damage show stark white colonies beside pigmented neighbors, and a live crown-of-thorns starfish beside freshly killed skeleton. Bleached colonies were photographed on both days: a massive colony on 25 April and plating and branching colonies on 26 April. A blind Claude computer-vision point count puts coral cover around 29%; nearby stations within 5 km (11-93% between 2014 and 2025) are different, named sites.

Max. depth dived
29.3 m
Water temp. during survey
30.4°Cii
+1.7°C vs the 2018 mean sea temperature (28.7°C)
ii Mean of the dive-average water temperatures of the 3 logged dives (30.44, 30.38, and 30.34°C), 25-26 April 2018 (dive log); the dive-computer minimum was 30.0°C on every dive.

21 independent survey stations shown with the program’s logo — click one to see how far it is from this site.

Four other CRD dive sites with their own pages within 5 km shown in orange — click a marker to open its page.

4 of the 19 photographs on this page are shown beside the text that discusses them under "Site description" below.

67891011121314151617181920

Photo credit & attribution

Site description

General benthic features

The wider frames show a reef whose framework is columnar and branching rather than tabulate: one is a flat of pale tan-cream columnar Porites-type colonies with brown foliose colonies and a mustard soft coral between them, broken by broad white sand and rubble channels, with surgeonfish and damselfish over it; another is a near-continuous field of salmon-tan fine-branched coral filling the frame, with a cream leathery soft coral, chartreuse crinoid, and a black antipatharian bush at the margin (e.g., Image 2, Image 3).

The fourth reef frame is the poorest ground in the set: a slope of large angular boulders and broken reef blocks coated in gray-green turf and coralline algae, carrying only a handful of small colonies, with damselfish and surgeonfish over it (e.g., Image 5).

Coral cover

Stressors

One close frame, which Anderson recorded as crown-of-thorns damage, shows two corymbose colonies, each roughly 30-40 cm across, stark white from base to branch tip with their structure intact, directly beside normally pigmented brown and olive colonies (e.g., Image 1); another frame of crown-of-thorns damage shows a white patch on a massive colony and a small white branching colony.

Another frame from the same dive shows a live crown-of-thorns starfish wedged in a crevice beside a patch of freshly killed white skeleton. On 25 April, a meter-scale massive colony on sand was bleached, uniformly pale blue-white with its corallites visible. Its edges carry old partial mortality, patches now covered by algae. On the 26 April dive, pale to stark-white plating colonies and a stark-white branching colony were bleached.

Comparisons with other data

We found no other surveys at this site as of 2026. Within 5 km, 21 independent stations recorded station-year means of 11–93% hard coral cover between 2014 and 2025; the nearest, Reef Check at Tanah Rata, 0.96 km away, read 38% in 2015.

Dive record

Three dives here on 25 and 26 April 2018 (16:35, 18:58, and 13:03; 54-61 minutes; max 13.7, 14.6, and 29.3 m; average 7-16 m) with dive-average water temperatures of 30.3-30.4°C (the dive-computer minimum was 30.0°C on every dive).

CV model comparison

Mean 29%, median 25% across 133 photos.
More infoA few colony-focused photos raise the mean; the median is the typical photo. No computer-vision method yet estimates coral cover accurately on new images, so treat this as indicative rather than a measurement; it is revised as the methods improve.
Headline: Claude computer vision — a blind point count of this site's own photographs.
More infoDINOv3 and CoralSCOP were run on the site's photographs (see each row's n) and are listed for comparison. No diver transect exists for this trip, so agreement between the rows is not accuracy, and no computer-vision method yet estimates coral cover accurately on new images; treat every row as indicative.
MethodHard coral cover (%)Photos (n) ± SE
In-house DINOv323.8n = 56 · SE 1.4
CoralSCOP edited36.3n = 132 · SE 1.9
Claude (edited photos)28.9n = 133 · SE 2.3

The two computer-vision methods disagree by 12.5 pp (23.8–36.3%) and read on both sides of Claude's blind point count (28.9%); the headline is Claude's blind point count because no transect or manual count exists here.

% coral cover by visit

Each visit is analyzed independently; these are not pooled into a single site mean. The two visits read 20–35%, 15 points apart: a difference beyond the 7-point method-noise floor (95% interval 7.4 to 23.9 points). The visits were 1 day apart, so this is variation between dives, not a change over time.

Date% coral coverStd. dev.Frames scored
2018-04-2535%±2977
2018-04-2620%±1956

Independent surveys nearby

Data availability near this site
Agency / programYear(s)Stations / distanceLink
Coral Triangle Center (CTC)2014–20199 stations, 1.22–4.98 kmRecords ↓
Reef Check2015–202512 stations, 0.96–4.96 kmRecords ↓
Hard coral cover over time — this site and every independent station within 5 km. Programs are shown separately because they use different methods at different stations; the lines are not one comparable series.
0%25%50%75%100%201420192025Coral Triangle Center (CTC) 2014: 40%Coral Triangle Center (CTC) 2014: 43%Coral Triangle Center (CTC) 2014: 49%Coral Triangle Center (CTC) 2015: 27%Coral Triangle Center (CTC) 2015: 35%Coral Triangle Center (CTC) 2015: 37%Coral Triangle Center (CTC) 2016: 33%Coral Triangle Center (CTC) 2016: 42%Coral Triangle Center (CTC) 2016: 47%Coral Triangle Center (CTC) 2017: 28%Coral Triangle Center (CTC) 2017: 43%Coral Triangle Center (CTC) 2017: 48%Coral Triangle Center (CTC) 2018: 39%Coral Triangle Center (CTC) 2018: 42%Coral Triangle Center (CTC) 2018: 47%Coral Triangle Center (CTC) 2019: 11%Coral Triangle Center (CTC) 2019: 31%Coral Triangle Center (CTC) 2019: 34%Coral Triangle Center (CTC) 2019: 35%Coral Triangle Center (CTC) 2019: 39%Coral Triangle Center (CTC) 2019: 53%Coral Triangle Center (CTC) 2019: 65%Coral Triangle Center (CTC) 2019: 67%Coral Triangle Center (CTC) 2019: 69%Reef Check 2015: 38%Reef Check 2015: 54%Reef Check 2015: 73%Reef Check 2015: 76%Reef Check 2016: 34%Reef Check 2016: 45%Reef Check 2016: 47%Reef Check 2016: 55%Reef Check 2016: 64%Reef Check 2017: 29%Reef Check 2017: 37%Reef Check 2017: 47%Reef Check 2017: 63%Reef Check 2018: 21%Reef Check 2018: 26%Reef Check 2018: 56%Reef Check 2018: 68%Reef Check 2018: 85%Reef Check 2019: 28%Reef Check 2019: 29%Reef Check 2019: 33%Reef Check 2019: 50%Reef Check 2019: 55%Reef Check 2019: 56%Reef Check 2019: 65%Reef Check 2019: 74%Reef Check 2020: 55%Reef Check 2022: 52%Reef Check 2022: 56%Reef Check 2023: 58%Reef Check 2024: 50%Reef Check 2024: 93%Reef Check 2025: 66%Reef Check 2025: 88%Coral Reef Diagnostics 2018: 29%Year-averaged across all programs: illustrative only; the programs differ in stations and method, so no trend is claimed (11 years)
Coral Triangle Center (CTC) Reef Check Coral Reef DiagnosticsYear-average (illustrative only, programs differ)

Within 5 km, 21 independent survey stations recorded hard coral cover in 107 surveys between 2014 and 2025. Of the 11 stations surveyed in more than one year, 6 declined (by 2.0–9.0 points) and 5 increased (by 3.0–12 points) between their first and latest surveys. The longest record, Pohon Miring (Reef Check, 4.96 km away), went from 73% (best patch) in 2015 to 66% in 2025 (mean of 2 surveys). Since 2021, station-year means average 56% (range 50–66%; n = 5 station-years from 14 surveys); 2 best-patch values above 70% are left out, as they are not site means. This site's own estimate (29%) sits within the range of these station-year means up to 2 km away (21–56%, excluding 2 best-patch values above 70% that are not a site mean); the methods differ, so the comparison is context, not a like-for-like test.

Collected by other programs using different methods (Reef Check uses point-intercept transects), so these are context for the figures above, not a like-for-like comparison. Where a station was surveyed more than once, the cell shows either the range of its values or, as a single value, the mean of surveys made in one year. Station names are not dive-site names. Values above 70% are marked “best patch”: surveys often target the densest coral on a reef, so these may overstate the site as a whole.

Show all 107 independent surveys
Independent survey data near this site
AgencySite / locationDateHard coral cover (%)DistanceLink
Coral Triangle Center (CTC)Mangku Batu (20)2014–201927–43% (6 surveys)1.22 kmCurrier K, Marine P, Welly M. 2019. Jejaring KKP Kepulauan Banda. MERMAID
Coral Triangle Center (CTC)Wali (12)2014–201935–43% (6 surveys)4.37 kmCurrier K, Marine P, Welly M. 2019. Jejaring KKP Kepulauan Banda. MERMAID
Coral Triangle Center (CTC)Syahrir Timur (11)2014–201935–53% (6 surveys)4.63 kmCurrier K, Marine P, Welly M. 2019. Jejaring KKP Kepulauan Banda. MERMAID
Reef CheckTanah Rata201538%0.96 km—
Reef CheckLava Flow2015–201963–76% (range of yearly means; 14 surveys) best patch2.52 km—
Reef CheckPulau Pisang West2015–201954–65% (range of yearly means; 14 surveys)4.29 km—
Reef CheckPohon Miring2015–202552–73% (range of yearly means; 15 surveys) best patch4.96 km—
Reef CheckAmpas Roti, Gunung Api2016–202426–50% (range of yearly means; 10 surveys)3.23 km—
Reef CheckPisang East2016–202237–56% (range of yearly means; 10 surveys)4.51 km—
Reef CheckBatu Kapal2016–201928–34% (range of yearly means; 5 surveys)4.56 km—
Reef CheckPantai Wali201747%, mean of 2 surveys (4 m and 10 m)4.26 km—
Reef CheckBandara2018–201921–33% (range of yearly means; 4 surveys)1.72 km—
Reef CheckBanda Besar 4.05201885%, mean of 2 surveys (6 m and 10 m) best patch4.96 km—
Reef CheckLampu Merah201956%, mean of 2 surveys (5 m and 10 m)1.57 km—
Coral Triangle Center (CTC)Karaka (06)201967%2.18 kmCurrier K, Marine P, Welly M. 2019. Jejaring KKP Kepulauan Banda. MERMAID
Coral Triangle Center (CTC)Gunung Api Timur (07)201939%2.19 kmCurrier K, Marine P, Welly M. 2019. Jejaring KKP Kepulauan Banda. MERMAID
Coral Triangle Center (CTC)Lava Flow (09)201969%2.43 kmCurrier K, Marine P, Welly M. 2019. Jejaring KKP Kepulauan Banda. MERMAID
Coral Triangle Center (CTC)Gunung Api Selatan (08)201911%3.31 kmCurrier K, Marine P, Welly M. 2019. Jejaring KKP Kepulauan Banda. MERMAID
Coral Triangle Center (CTC)Batu Kapal (10)201931%4.59 kmCurrier K, Marine P, Welly M. 2019. Jejaring KKP Kepulauan Banda. MERMAID
Coral Triangle Center (CTC)Pohon Miring (16)201965%4.98 kmCurrier K, Marine P, Welly M. 2019. Jejaring KKP Kepulauan Banda. MERMAID
Reef CheckLava Flow2024–202588–93% (range of yearly means; 4 surveys) best patch1.15 km—

Data & links

All images from Coral Reef Diagnostics. Data are from Coral Reef Diagnostics and the organizations named in the data sources above.

© Coral Reef Diagnostics.