Coral Reef Diagnostics

Saba - Man-of-War Shoals

⬇ Download this page as a report card
05
Photo: Anderson Mayfield/Coral Reef Diagnostics
Country
Survey date(s)
2026-02-21
Coordinates
17.6467, -63.2551
Coral cover
3.7%
Claude computer vision (102 photos) · other methods below
Observations
not yet tagged for this site
Heat stress
Today’s heat load
16 Sep 2026 · Alert Level 1
5-year thermal stress load
5-year mean max. degree heating weeks (DHW)
2021–2025
NOAA Coral Reef Watch — Leeward Caribbean Islands virtual station
i 5-year mean max. DHW is the mean of the annual maximum DHWs over the five complete years named above, not conditions today.
More infoLeeward Caribbean Islands (NOAA CRW virtual station) · Eastern Caribbean ecoregion mean=13.1°C-heating weeks
Photographs
54
Site summary

The high-relief dive of the Saba set: basalt spires and pinnacles split by narrow canyons, crowned by some of the biggest barrel and tube sponges of the trip, with corals present but secondary. Caribbean reef sharks patrol the walls, and a green turtle and a queen angelfish sheltering inside a barrel sponge were also seen.

Max. depth dived
21.6 m
dive-log maximum
Water temp. during survey
26.5°Cii
-1.7°C vs the 12 months to 2026-08 mean sea temperature (28.2°C)
ii mean of 1 logged dive(s) at "Man-of-War Shoals" in dive_log_master_20260826.csv, joined on log_depth_basis name 20260921

Three independent survey stations shown with the program’s logo — click one to see how far it is from this site.

Three other CRD dive sites within 5 km shown in orange — click a marker to open its page.

27 of these 54 photographs are shown beside the text that discusses them under "Site description" below.

1456712192021232426282932353637414243454649505155

Photo credit & attribution

Site description

Setting

This is the high-relief site of the set: basalt spires and pinnacles with narrow clefts and canyons between them, near-vertical walls dropping to pale sand and loose rubble aprons, and shallower crests that catch full sunlight (e.g., Image 16, Image 17, Image 25).

General benthic features

Cover is overwhelmingly sponge and crustose coralline algae over dead framework (e.g., Image 8).

Giant barrel sponges (Xestospongia muta) appear in dozens of frames - brick-red, salmon, and tan, several a meter across, one cluster of five or six grown together on the crest, several with torn or pale rims (e.g., Image 2, Image 11, Image 30).

Golden tube sponges (Aplysina fistularis) form large stands on the shallow crests and orange elephant-ear sponges (Agelas clathrodes) punctuate the wall faces, with olive-mustard encrusting sheets, mint-turquoise sponges, dark red foliose sponges, gray and lavender vase sponges, and abundant scarlet encrusting sponge (e.g., Image 13, Image 14, Image 40, Image 44).

Gorgonians include sea plumes, sea rods, black bushy colonies, and black-coral bushes silhouetted on the wall; green bushy macroalgae carpets parts of the wall and crest (e.g., Image 10, Image 15, Image 31, Image 38).

Stony coral is present but subordinate. Great star coral (Montastraea cavernosa) gives the best colonies - several healthy domes with raised corallites, one with a turf-colonized dead patch (e.g., Image 22, Image 33).

Grooved brain coral (Diploria labyrinthiformis) recurs as olive-green heads, in one frame a live colony sitting beside a dead turf-covered brain skeleton, several with small white lesions (e.g., Image 53, Image 54).

Plating star corals of the Orbicella type appear as crowded-corallite plates, one being overgrown by a sponge (e.g., Image 3, Image 27, Image 39).

Agaricia plates, Porites astreoides knobs, a small branching coral stand, and green-striped corallimorphs (Discosoma) fill the cryptic spaces (e.g., Image 47).

Coral cover

Coral cover: 3.7% — a blind Claude computer-vision point count of 102 of Anderson's unedited photographs (20 points per photo; water, fish, and obstructions excluded). Other computer-vision methods are listed in the method table. Frames were screened before scoring: open sand, mid-water, blown-out, and burst-duplicate frames, dive computers, topside, and diver shots, blue-light fluorescence, and macros were all removed.

Fish and other fauna

Fauna is the strongest of the four dives: Caribbean reef sharks (Carcharhinus perezi) in four frames, two together on the wall; a small nurse shark under an overhang; a green turtle on the crest across three frames; a queen angelfish inside a barrel sponge; grunt and margate schools; heavy sergeant-major, blue tang, black durgon, creole wrasse, and chromis presence; a rock beauty, a grouper, a trumpetfish, a bearded fireworm, and crinoids (e.g., Image 18, Image 34, Image 48, Image 52).

One invasive lionfish (Pterois volitans).

Comparisons with other data

No independent survey was made at this exact site; the nearest ones are listed in the table below.

Dive record

Man-of-War Shoals, Saba National Marine Park, reviewed frame by frame from all 109 unedited stills of dive 2, 21 Feb 2026.

CV model comparison

As of September 2026 no computer-vision method estimates coral cover accurately on new images, so treat this as indicative rather than a measurement; it is revised as the methods improve.
Headline: Claude computer vision — a blind point count of this site's own photographs (Anderson, 2026-09-27: Claude CV is the main coral-cover value).
More infoDINOv3 and CoralSCOP were run on the same photos and are listed for comparison. Coralscapes v2 and v1 were also run but are not shown: Anderson does not consider Coralscapes reliable for these photos. No diver transect exists for this trip, so agreement between the rows is not accuracy, and as of September 2026 no computer-vision method estimates coral cover accurately on new images; treat every row as indicative.
MethodHard-coral cover (%)
In-house DINOv319.8
CoralSCOP unedited29.3
Claude3.7

Independent surveys nearby

Hard coral cover over time — this site and every independent station within 5 km. Programs are shown separately because they use different methods at different stations; the lines are not one comparable series.
0%10%20242026MERMAID project “Saba_Marina_Relocation”* 2024: 1.7%MERMAID project “Saba_Marina_Relocation”* 2024: 6.5%MERMAID project “Saba_Marina_Relocation”* 2025: 5.8%MERMAID project “Saba_Marina_Relocation”* 2025: 10%Dr. Coral (CRD) 2026: 3.7%Year-averaged across all programs: no detectable trend (-0.20 pp per year, not separable from zero; 3 years)
MERMAID project “Saba_Marina_Relocation”* Dr. Coral (CRD)Year-average (no detectable trend)

Within 5 km, 3 independent survey stations recorded hard coral cover in 7 surveys between 2024 and 2025. Of the 1 station surveyed in more than one year, 1 increased between their first and latest surveys. The longest record, Black_Rock_Donor (MERMAID project “Saba_Marina_Relocation”*, 3.98 km away), went from 1.7% in 2024 to 10% in 2025. Surveys since 2021 average 6.0% (range 1.7–10%, n=4). This site's own estimate (3.7%) sits within the recent range (1.7–10%); the methods differ, so the comparison is context, not a like-for-like test.

Collected by other programs using different methods (MERMAID is a data platform: each MERMAID row names the organization that did the survey, and its method is in the row's hover text. *Conducted by citizen scientists), so these are context for the figures above, not a like-for-like comparison. Where a station was surveyed more than once the range is shown. Station names are not dive-site names.

Independent survey data near this site
AgencySite / locationDateHard coral cover (%)DistanceLink
MERMAID project “Saba_Marina_Relocation”*Black_Rock_Donor2024–20251.7–10% (2 surveys)3.98 kmBean T, Gould K, Re E. 2025. Saba_Marina_Relocation. MERMAID
MERMAID project “Saba_Marina_Relocation”*Hole_in_the_Corner_(HITC)_Recipient20246.5%4.52 kmBean T, Gould K, Re E. 2025. Saba_Marina_Relocation. MERMAID
MERMAID project “Saba_Marina_Relocation”*Black_Rock_Donor (mean of 2 surveys, 2024–2025)20255.8% (4 surveys)3.98 kmBean T, Gould K, Re E. 2025. Saba_Marina_Relocation. MERMAID

Data & links

All images from Coral Reef Diagnostics. Data are from Coral Reef Diagnostics and the organizations named in the data-sources table above.

© Coral Reef Diagnostics.