Coral Reef Diagnostics

Indonesia - Komodo NP: Tatawa Besar

Reef Check Foundation
⬇ Download this page as a report card
05
Photo: Anderson Mayfield/Coral Reef Diagnostics
Country
Survey date(s)
2009-08-16
2019-01-19
2019-01-22
2019-01-27
Coordinates
-8.5270, 119.6520
Coral cover
22%
Claude computer vision (155 edited photos) · other methods below
Observations
mortalitydiseasebleachingpredation
Heat stress
Today’s heat load
16 Sep 2026 · No heat stress
5-year thermal stress load
5-year mean max. degree heating weeks (DHW)
2021–2025
NOAA Coral Reef Watch — East Nusa Tenggara virtual station
i 5-year mean max. DHW is the mean of the annual maximum DHWs over the five complete years named above, not conditions today.
More infoEast Nusa Tenggara (NOAA CRW virtual station) · Lesser Sunda ecoregion mean=6.9°C-heating weeks
Photographs
50
Site summary
Read this summary in:

A sloping Komodo reef dominated by a fluorescent orange soft coral, huge sponges, and abundant, very diverse hard coral, with high fish biomass, giant clams, two mantas, a turtle, a Napoleon wrasse, and a rare dogtooth tuna. At 23°C it was easily the coldest dive of the trip, possibly made during an upwelling event, and large rubble areas at 5-7 m were blanketed in soft corals.

Max. depth dived
25.0 m
deepest of 4 logged dives
Water temp. during survey
26.1°Cii
-2.3°C vs the 2009, 2019 mean sea temperature (28.4°C)
ii Dive-computer reading of 79°F, converted; reported to one decimal because the instrument resolved whole degrees Fahrenheit.

Six independent survey stations shown with the program’s logo — click one to see how far it is from this site.

Seven other CRD dive sites within 5 km shown in orange — click a marker to open its page.

5 of these 50 photographs are shown beside the text that discusses them under "Site description" below.

67891011121314151617181920212223242526272829303132333435363738394041424344454647484950

Photo credit & attribution

Site description

Setting

24-25ºC (cold), 30% oxygen. poor viz=8 m, high particulate load, gentle current, a typical sloping reef dominated by a fluorescent orange soft coral, small massive Porites, Diploastrea, Pocillopora verrucosa, giant clams, small digitate Acropora, Platygyra, barrel sponges, Stylophora pistillata, high fish biomass, and diversity (though small mean size), P. rus (small), Pocillopora acuta, fire coral, some areas dominated by massive sponges, 2-3-m diameter manta, first Napoleon wrasse, Fungia, Galaxea, fairly high relief/structure compared to some reefs in the area (e.g., Image 1, Image 2).

Temp.=23.3ºC. 30% oxygen. 23ºC=easily the coldest dive of the trip. It is entirely possible that we were diving in the middle of an upwelling event given the poor viz (5-6 m) and cold temperatures (23-24ºC) (e.g., Image 4).

Water looked nutrient-rich, and fish life was more impressive than at many other sites.

General benthic features

Coral was very abundant. Stylophora pistillata=common, Hydnophora, Pocillopora eydouxi, Isopora, some table Acropora, finger Porites, Tubastrea (green), high Acropora diversity. Not much coral above 11 m. Seriatopora hystrix, fire coral, and soft corals all common in shallows. Large areas of rubble dominated by soft corals covering huge areas of 5-7 m, another manta at end of dive (e.g., Image 5).

Huge sponges dominated the habitat in many places. High coral cover and very colorful. Hard coral+sponge-dominated habitat for most of dive. Some coral rubble being colonized by CCA and other algae (e.g., Image 3).

Soft corals only dominant in shallows (3-5 m).

Coral cover

Coral cover: 22% — a blind Claude computer-vision point count of 155 of Anderson's edited photographs (20 points per photo; water, fish, and obstructions excluded). Other computer-vision methods are listed in the method table.

Stressors

No crown-of-thorns starfish (COTS) or other corallivores evident.

Fish and other fauna

Black tip reef shark. Saw a turtle. High reef fish biomass. Dogtooth tuna (among few of trip).

Comparisons with other data

No independent survey was made at this exact site; the nearest ones are listed in the table below.

Dive record

2019-1-22 dive 3: Tatawa Besar (#14). 14:52-15:50 (58 min). Max depth=18 m. 2019-1-27 dive 2: Tatawa Besar round 2 (#33; my 30th of trip): 10:30-11:28 (58 min). Max. depth=18.3 m.

Other notes

Though a virtual repeat of our previous dive to this site, it was nevertheless lovely. Essentially shivered the whole time.

CV model comparison

As of September 2026 no computer-vision method estimates coral cover accurately on new images, so treat this as indicative rather than a measurement; it is revised as the methods improve.
Headline: Claude computer vision — a blind point count of this site's own photographs (Anderson, 2026-09-27: Claude CV is the main coral-cover value).
More infoDINOv3 and CoralSCOP were run on the same photos and are listed for comparison. Coralscapes v2 and v1 were also run but are not shown: Anderson does not consider Coralscapes reliable for these photos. No diver transect exists for this trip, so agreement between the rows is not accuracy, and as of September 2026 no computer-vision method estimates coral cover accurately on new images; treat every row as indicative.
MethodHard-coral cover (%)
In-house DINOv323.9
CoralSCOP edited34.2
Claude (edited photos)22.0

% coral cover by visit

Each visit is analyzed independently; these are not pooled into a single site mean.

Date% coral coverStd. dev.Frames scored
2019-01-2220%±2171
2019-01-2724%±2284

Independent surveys nearby

Data availability near this site
Agency / programYear(s)Stations / distanceLink
Reef Check20205 stations, 1.10–4.16 kmRecords ↓
WWF-US / WWF-Indonesia20161 station, 1.59 kmRecords ↓
Hard coral cover over time — this site and every independent station within 5 km. Programs are shown separately because they use different methods at different stations; the lines are not one comparable series.
0%15%30%45%60%201620182020WWF-US / WWF-Indonesia 2016: 40%Reef Check 2020: 8.8%Reef Check 2020: 10%Reef Check 2020: 47%Reef Check 2020: 48%Reef Check 2020: 51%Dr. Coral (CRD) 2019: 22%Year-averaged across all programs: no detectable trend (-2.73 pp per year, not separable from zero; 3 years)
WWF-US / WWF-Indonesia Reef Check Dr. Coral (CRD)Year-average (no detectable trend)

Within 5 km, 6 independent survey stations recorded hard coral cover in 11 surveys between 2016 and 2020. The most recent nearby survey is from 2020, so these values predate recent heat stress. This site's own estimate (22%) sits within the range of these surveys (8.8–51%); the methods differ, so the comparison is context, not a like-for-like test.

Collected by other programs using different methods (Reef Check uses point-intercept transects), so these are context for the figures above, not a like-for-like comparison. Where a station was surveyed more than once the range is shown. Station names are not dive-site names.

Independent survey data near this site
AgencySite / locationDateHard coral cover (%)DistanceLink
WWF-US / WWF-IndonesiaTNK06201640% (2 surveys)1.59 kmAmkieltiela, Abdillah T, Amkieltiela A, Andradi-Brown D, Lazuardi E. 2016. Komodo MPA. MERMAID
Reef CheckSiaba Besar (Sector 1)202051% (2 surveys)1.10 km—
Reef CheckSiaba Besar (Sector 2)202047% (2 surveys)1.10 km—
Reef CheckMawan (Sector 1)202010% (2 surveys)2.04 km—
Reef CheckMawan (Sector 2)20208.8%2.04 km—
Reef CheckPengah Kecil (Sector 1) SW Side202048% (2 surveys)4.16 km—

Data & links

All images from Coral Reef Diagnostics. Data are from Coral Reef Diagnostics and the organizations named in the data-sources table above.

© Coral Reef Diagnostics.