Indonesia - Komodo NP: Siaba Kecil

General benthic features

A low-rugosity reef — flattened by the high current — but almost completely plastered in living cover. Anderson recorded extremely high coral cover at 15 m, maybe 80–90%, and 50–60% cover at 15 m on the second dive. Acropora is the defining genus. Large areas of 100% Acropora cover at 15 m, massive swaths at 7–8 m, beautiful Acropora meadows in the shallows, and high Acropora diversity overall. One wide frame is a continuous branching Acropora thicket running to the limit of visibility (e.g., Image 5).

5

Some areas are dominated by plating Acropora, with occasional large Acropora tables — one photographed table is over a meter across, olive-green with a clean white growing margin and structurally intact (e.g., Image 2).

2

Large areas of Acropora crusts (encrusting basal plates) are noted, and encrusting Isopora (species uncertain) was recorded. Pocilloporids are well represented: Pocillopora verrucosa, Pocillopora eydouxi, Stylophora pistillata, small Seriatopora hystrix (common on the second dive), and Seriatopora caliendrum. The first Pocillopora acuta of the trip was seen here and several more followed as the dive progressed; it was relatively common in places. Pigmentation was very dark. A close-up frame shows a pocilloporid so heavily pigmented it reads near-black, its verrucae picked out only by pale polyp tips (e.g., Image 1).

1

Nearly all Seriatopora caliendrum colonies were fluorescent green. Also recorded: Montipora, finger Porites, Porites rus, Pachyseris, Plerogyra, Galaxea, and meandroid brain corals visible in the wide frames. Most of this hard coral is overgrowing crustose-coralline-algae-consolidated rubble rather than sitting on solid reef framework — the pavement between colonies is visibly pink and magenta with coralline crusts. There is an interesting mix of hard and soft coral at 20 m, and several areas are blanketed by soft corals. One frame is an unbroken carpet of pulsing xeniid soft coral filling the entire field of view; at 3–4 m there was soft coral as far as the eye could see, at 11 m soft-coral carpets, and at 5–6 m large areas dominated by soft corals with only some Acropora (e.g., Image 4).

4

The reef was very colorful, albeit scoured: the cryptic substrate carries vivid crimson and magenta encrusting sponges, tunicates, bushy black hydroids or gorgonians, and green calcareous algae, and the coral is interspersed with beautiful sponges including maroon tube sponges (e.g., Image 3).

3

Coral cover

• Reference: Claude CV point count (this site's photos)
• Coral cover: 25% — a blind Claude computer-vision point count of 72 of Anderson's edited photographs (20 points per photo; water, fish, and obstructions excluded). Other computer-vision methods are listed in the method table.
• The Claude value sits well below Anderson's own in situ impression of 80–90% cover at 15 m and large areas of 100% Acropora at 15 m.

Stressors

On the 26 January dive (northeast side; no photographs), Anderson logged slimy algae, potentially cyanobacteria, in some areas at 3–6 m, and red and brown algae in some areas. On the 19 January dive, one frame shows a dark, filamentous mat (algae or possibly cyanobacteria) blanketing a patch of dead branching coral beside living colonies (e.g., Image 45).

45

Stinging hydroids are present. Evidence of over-fishing was noted — many small reef fish but few large ones, with a single large barracuda the exception. Standing dead Acropora skeleton is visible in the wide frames, still holding branch shape but overgrown with yellow-green turf and encrusting growth, sitting immediately below the living thicket. Small reef fish were seen living in Acropora with what appeared to be isopod parasites attached to the head. No bleaching was recorded on any of these dives, although a computer-vision point count called 1.0% of coral points bleached (2 of 72 photos). No crown-of-thorns starfish (COTS) or other corallivores were evident.

Fish and other fauna

Large angelfish and giant trevally on the first dive; one large barracuda on the second. Turtles on both dives, and a small manta ray on 26 Jan. A very large anemone, roughly 1 m in diameter. Lionfish, very common here. The first moray of the trip was seen on this dive. A giant clam, and spectacular small reef-fish life at 4 m. The wide frames are busy with anthias, small damselfish, and butterflyfish working the Acropora meadow, plus a loose school of red-and-white fish over the thicket. Tubastraea (the non-symbiotic orange cup coral) is rare here.

Comparisons with other data

Reef Check surveyed a nearby station (Mawan (Sector 1)), 0.49 km from the pin; we could not confirm that it is the same reef. Within 5 km, six independent stations (Reef Check and WWF-US / WWF-Indonesia) recorded station-year means of 8.8–51% hard coral cover between 2016 and 2020; the nearest, Reef Check at Mawan (Sector 1), 0.49 km away, read a mean of 10% in 2020.

Dive record

Island site in Komodo National Park, dived on 16 Aug 2009 and twice in January 2019 — 19 Jan 2019 (11:02–11:59, 57 min, max depth 21.9 m, 31% oxygen) and 26 Jan 2019 (07:48–08:46, 58 min, max depth 18.3 m, 30% oxygen). Average water temperature 26.1°C on 19 January and 26.7°C on 26 January 2019 (dive computer). The 19 Jan dive was, in Anderson's words, a great hard coral dive, with very high average live coral cover at 5–15 m but limited visibility that varied with depth. On 26 Jan the northeast side was dived instead, which evidently experiences much stronger currents depending on the tides — near-Lembongan-like current at the start, though it caused no problems. On the 19 January dive, strong current drained Anderson's air quickly. Current increased with depth on the first dive, with a coincident drop in visibility; after turning the corner on the second dive, visibility went from 5 m to 20 m and the water warmed. The SD card malfunctioned on 26 Jan, so no photographs exist from that dive; the photographs on this page are from the 19 January 2019 dive.